Best Key Lock Box For Airbnb Self Check-In 2019 Reviews And Buyer’s Guide

26 Models Considered

74 Hours of Research

5 Experts Interviewed

Need a key lock box that keeps the keys of your Airbnb property secure as well as allows self-check-in? We did all the research and tests including hiring experts with loads of experience in key lock boxes. As a result, we can determine that Master Lock 5425D is the best key lock box for Airbnb. The lock box is weatherproof and even works in low light conditions. However, you want something smarter that notifies you every time the box accessed, you must go for Igloohome Smart Keybox 2.

Top Pick

Product

Editor's Pick

Runner Up

Budget Pick

Name

Master Lock 5425D

Igloohome Smart Keybox 2

ORIA Key Storage Lock Box

Best For

Top Weatherproof Key Lock Box

Smart Key Lock Box For Airbnb

Budget-friendly Key Lock Box

Pros

Light up dial.Strong metal housing for the keys.Installation is easy, and the box is well secured.

Guests are not required to install the app.Dustproof as well as waterproof.If the lock is not locked properly, it relocks itself after 60 seconds.

Very simple to use and install.Ample storage capacity for the keys.Inexpensive compared to similar lock boxes.

Cons

Expensive compared to other similar lock boxes.

ExpensiveNo backlight for low light visibility.

No easy to use in low light conditions.

Buy On

Check Price

Check Price

Check Price

Editor's Pick

Product

Name

Master Lock 5425D

Best For

Top Weatherproof Key Lock Box

Pros

Light up dial.Strong metal housing for the keys.Installation is easy, and the box is well secured.

Cons

Expensive compared to other similar lock boxes.

Buy On

Check Price

Runner Up

Product

Name

Igloohome Smart Keybox 2

Best For

Smart Key Lock Box For Airbnb

Pros

Guests are not required to install the app.Dustproof as well as waterproof.If the lock is not locked properly, it relocks itself after 60 seconds.

Cons

ExpensiveNo backlight for low light visibility.

Buy On

Check Price

Budget Pick

Product

Name

ORIA Key Storage Lock Box

Best For

Budget-friendly Key Lock Box

Pros

Very simple to use and install.Ample storage capacity for the keys.Inexpensive compared to similar lock boxes.

Cons

No easy to use in low light conditions.

Buy On

Check Price

Best Key Lock Box For Airbnb Self Check In

1. Master Lock 5425D – Top Weatherproof Key Lock Box

Sale

Master Lock 5425D

• LOCK BOX APPLICATION: For indoor and outdoor use; wall mount lock box is best used for key and access card storage;...
• EASE OF USE: Resettable 4 digit combination for keyless convenience; Large Open Lever for more comfortable use
• LIGHT UP DIALS: Large easy to read light up dials for better visibility in low light conditions; Dials light up...

Check Price

The Master Lock 5425D is a key lock box with light up dials that is suitable for both outdoor and indoor use. As an Airbnb owner, you want to use your key lock box mostly for the outside. The biggest factor that tests any key lock box outdoors is the weather. The Master Lock 5425D is weatherproof and highly durable as it made of metal.

One thing that we like is the light up dial which allows your guest to access the box even in low light conditions. We tested it in the dark and were able to enter the combination with ease. However, you will have to keep an eye on the battery. There is no indicator for the low battery. For safety, you would be required to change the batteries every two months.

Bottom Line

We liked the box for its capacity and durability. Even the light up dial, is a good feature to have for a key lock box. Overall there is a lot to like about the box for an Airbnb owner. For us it is the best Airbnb self check in lockbox.

2. Igloohome Smart Keybox 2 – Smart Key Lock Box For Airbnb

Igloohome Smart Keybox 2

• The new and improved Smart Lockbox designed for home, property and business owners to grant access from anywhere around...
• Unlock via time sensitive PIN codes or Bluetooth keys that you can create and control on our free igloohome app.
• Includes 2 shackle sizes which fit on most door knobs and door handles. Additionally, it can be hung on fences or...

Check Price

There are plenty of smart locks but not lock boxes. Even when we’re looking for lock boxes with smart capabilities, we hardly found many options. One of our experts suggested we Igloohome. It fairly new company but they are growing fast due to their innovative key box. Even we were impressed when we looked at it for the first time.

However, what is the biggest selling point of the box is smart capability. It is enabled by a phone app. The owner can change the codes from anywhere in the world. The homeowner can create unique PIN codes or Bluetooth keys. Also, schedule it depending on the guest’s arrival at the property. And of course, you have access to logs so that you can keep an eye when the lock box is accessed.

Bottom Line

If your Airbnb property is in another state or even country, the Igloohome Smart Keybox 2 is accessible with ease. We tested its security and durability. It is on par with the best key lock boxe for vacation rental.

3. ORIA Key Storage Lock Box – Budget-friendly Key Lock Box

Sale

ORIA Key Storage

• Durable material: This key lock box is made of zinc alloy and heavy-duty steel, which can protect the box from...
• High Security: This product is an adjustable combinations lock with 4 dials. It can offer 10000 combination.
• Large storage capacity: The box has large space which you can place 5 keys at most. You can put your house keys or car...

Check Price

Do you want a strong and secure lock box not willing to spend much? ORIA Key Storage Lock Box is a good option for the Airbnb owners with a limited budget. With a price range of just $25, you get all the necessary features to require for the key lock for Airbnb. It has a combination lock and can store around five keys.

Overall the built quality is really good. Even when you hit it with a heavy object like hammer or stone, it can withstand the impact. Also, it can withstand any weather. We tested it with both dust and water; it worked fine.

Bottom Line

Looking at it’s built and capacity, it can easily compete with the best of the key lock boxes. It is the best airbnb self check in lockbox for users with a limited budget.

4. Master Lock 5423D- Key Lock box For Key Cards

Sale

Master Lock 5423D

• Key lock box enables secure storage of up to five keys; designed for installation to a wall or fixed object (hardware...
• Set your own alpha/numeric combination lock box; reset the combination for multiple personalized combination code...
• For indoor and outdoor use; key safe is constructed with a metal body for durability and weather cover to protect...

Check Price

Most of the key lock boxes where suitable for the different types of keys but as an Airbnb owner, it is quite possible you use key cards. In such cases, you must get something like Master Lock 5423D. It is a much better storage capacity than most of the boxes. In addition to key cards, it uses a push button lock. Using the keypad, you can set a password with 12 letters, numbers or use a combination of both.

The built quality is really good. It uses 79 mm wide metal body for sturdiness and durability. We tested it for impact; it can withstand heavy blows. Next, we tested it for different weather conditions. The body is antirust and also dustproof. We also exposed it to some wet conditions, the box worked fine, and the content of the box was dry.

Bottom Line

We recommend the Master Lock 5423D only if you are looking for a key lock box that can accommodate key cards with keys. There is ample space for both with this option.

5. Kingsley Guard-a-key Lockbox- Portable Key Lock Box For Airbnb

Sale

Kingsley Guard-a-key Lockbox

• Durable All Metal Construction
• Fits Over 5 Keys
• 10,000 Possible Combinations

Check Price

If you are looking for a lockbox that can be removable and not fixed, a lock box like Kingsley Guard-a-key is a very good choice. It can store up to 5 keys and uses combination lock which is easy to open. The overall weight of the lock is only 9.4 ounces; it can be removed and stored it somewhere else.

We liked the build quality of the lockbox. Even if you hit with hammer or stones, it doesn’t budge. Outer black cover blends well with the surrounding. As it is made of steel, it is corrosion resistant and can withstand rain and dust. Also keeps the keys secure from the weather.

Bottom Line

We won’t’ recommend you to use lockbox for the main door, but if you want to secure special gates or secure things like a bicycle on your Airbnb property, it is really useful. It is cheap. Hence you can buy a few at once so that if one is lost, you can replace it.

6. Kidde AccessPoint 001014- Most Durable Key Lock Box

Kidde AccessPoint 001014

• Portable, easy-to-use spin dial combination lock locking box; padlock stores up to 5 keys mounted anywhere
• Key lock box allows for easy key-access in real estate, construction, and general security applications
• The key lock safe has a spin dial combination for quick entrance into the box and to retrieving your keys; 10,000...

Check Price

Most of the lockboxes that we have mentioned in this list have either combination locks or push button. The Kidde AccessPoint 001014 has a dial lock with 10,000 different combinations as it uses letters compared to numbers. It works well when installed on the wall. Though it looks small, it was heavy compared to other similar locks. It is due to its construction.

We tested it for water resistance. Though the outer covering is water resistant, it does not completely seal the water off. In conditions such as heavy rain, the water will zip into the cavity. Many keys are prone to corrosion. Especially, old keys are prone to corrosion.

Bottom Line

If you are looking for the lockbox that has much thicker walls to keep the content secure, the Kidde AccessPoint 001014 is best. Also, the dial lock is hard to crack because of the 10,000 combinations.

7. KeyGuard SL-590 Wall Mount Lock Box- High Storage Capacity Key Lock Box

Sale

KeyGuard SL-590

• KeyGuard lockbox provides sturdy and secure keyless access for friends, family, or guests that need entry when no one is...
• Codes are easily memorized with familiar phone style keypad - no more spinning dials and scrunching your eyes to see if...
• KeyGuard provides ample and highly secure interior storage space for your valuables - it will hold keys as well as car...

Check Price

The KeyGuard SL-590 probably has the largest storage capacity among all. It cannot just store a few individual keys, but it can store several bunches of keys. Also, it can store credit cards, key cards car remote, etc. It may not look great in terms of aesthetics, but it secures and uses push-button locks.

The built quality seems nice. However, we have tested much better locks in terms of construction. It can save the content of the box from a drizzle, but with heavy rain, you might find some water inside it.

Bottom Line

If you are looking for lockbox with huge storage capacity, there is not another key lock box that could come close to KeyGuard SL-590. It is the best key lock box for Airbnb in terms of storage capacity.

Buyer’s Guide- What To Consider While Buying The Key Lock Box For Airbnb?

There are several aspects of a key lock box. By understand each aspect you will be able to choose the best key lock box for Airbnb. These aspects were identified with the help of experts. We have two experts from sales, two from the manufacturing and one Airbnb owner. Let’s look at these aspects one by one:

1. Installation

There are various places a key lock box can be installed. Firstly, it can be installed either inside the house or outside. But most of the Airbnb owner wants the box for the outdoor. Even at the outdoors, the lock box can be installed either on the wall or the door. According to our experts, the most secure installation of lock box is on the wall. If you install it on the door, you install it on the handle or any other fixture which is removable. However, if keep the key lock boxes on the wall is more of a permanent installation which is more suitable for Airbnb property.

2. Locking System

You might have observed there are almost three types of locking system—dial, push button and combination. If you compare each type, all of them are secure and does the job of keeping your keys safe. The only thing you have to look at it is the ease of use with the locking system. The big reason being, for Airbnb property, you will have a new person accessing it every few days. Guest won’t be familiar with the lockbox. Eeven if you have best airbnb self check in lockbox, but it has a complicated locking system, the guest will have tough time opening the lock box.

During our tests, we noticed that with push button lock using combination number and letters can easily frustrate users as it requires to push a single button several times for certain letter or number. If even a single digit is wrong, the user will have to start again. While with dial or combination lock, all user has to do is bring the dial to the right point and leave it. Chances of going wrong are almost zero if the password is known. This is why we like Master Lock 5425D

3. Storage Capacity

You might find a variety of lock boxes depending on the storage capacity. It is not necessary you have to get the biggest lock box. But have to identify how many keys or key card you want to leave outside your Airbnb property for your guests. Depending on that choose the right key lock box. With Igloohome Smart Keybox 2 you can store 3-4 keys which is fine if you want something compact. And if want to store bunches of keys and cards go with KeyGuard SL-590.

4. Durability

A most important aspect after the locking system is the built quality. If the lock box is not durable against impact, weather, and dust, it is not the most secure lock box. You want your lock box to take heavy blows of impact in case anyone forcefully tries to access the box. In addition to theft, lock box must be able to protect the content of the box from dust and weather. Your box may be weather proof, but your keys may not be. So make sure the box is well sealed. The box that passed our durability test with flying colors is Master Lock 5425D and Master Lock 5423D .

How We Conducted Tested Key Lock Boxes For Airbnb?

We began our testing process by identifying the bestselling and most popular key lock boxes in the market. With the help of experts and sellers, we were able to identify 26 key lock boxes that are well suited for Airbnb property. They are popular as well as have good sales numbers. We acquired all 26 the lock boxes from the seller for testing. Next, we began the process of determining the testing parameters. Depending on the features and what the users required from the best key lock boxes for Airbnb, we identified the most important parameters.

The parameters for testing included durability, storage capacity, ease of access, installation, and locking system. All the tests were designed to test the lockbox on these parameters. We made sure that every tool we used for measurement are well calibrated and accurate. We also made sure that we create an environment or situation which resembles the real-life situation so that the results are not just mere numbers but actual practical depiction.

In addition to tests also contact existing users of each 26 lockboxes to know how they have been performing after the purchase. Considering all the data and information we had on all lock boxes, we scored each lockbox for the three most important factor safety, durability and ease of use. Each member of our team scored the boxes separately. After we had the overall score, we sort listed the seven best key lock box for Airbnb. Here is the scorecard:

Final Thought

Securing the Airbnb property is your most important priority, and you also want to make the stay of your guest comfortable. Any system you install for your Airbnb property must be a combination of both factors. Our list of best airbnb self check in lockbox also ensures that both requirements are fulfilled. Beyond that, you have found your requirements. We advise you to go through our comprehensive buyer’s guide to understand your requirements.