Flood barriers have proved their worth in storms and floods to protect your home. Now there are huge number of manufacturers offering flood barriers. But considering so many options, it is hard to tell which works until a flood hits you. You don’t want to be in a situation where flood hits and you realize your flood barriers don’t work. So to help you avoid such disastrous situation we tested several flood barriers. If don’t you have time to read the complete post, we recommend you to buy the Quick Dam Flood Barrier. It is the best flood barrier we tested.
1. Quick Dam – Best Self Activating Kit
- Water Activated Flood Barriers, Rated #1 in Flood Control
- Grows to 3.5in high in minutes, just get them wet
- Long, flexible design creates all sorts of shapes
The Quick Dam has been offering the flood barriers for homes. They have a wide range of flood barriers which suits the needs of every kind of users. While we were talking to the existing customers, they had wonderful things to say about Quick Dam Flood Barrier. Many admitted Quick Dam flood barrier saved their home from several floods and storms.
We also twisted them into different shapes to see if they can be used for some unconventional spaces. We liked the fact that they are flexible and easy to carry around. When you compare to sandbags, you can set up a flood much faster with Quick Dam barriers. We also tested against a current of water. Not too strong but strong enough to move a 3-pound object. The objective was to see if the barrier moves out of place but it didn’t. It has dual chamber design to keep it in place even against a strong current of water.
It is the best water activated flood barrier. They are easy to deploy and takes hardly any time. So if your house or office is prone to flash flood, having something like Quick Dam Flood Barrier is much better precaution idea than sandbags.
2. Hydrabarrier Standard Water Diversion Tubes – Best Water Filled Tubes For Home
- 6 feet long x 8 inches wide x 4 inches high
- Easy to use - Weighs about a pound when empty
- Fill with standard garden hose, holds up to 7.5 gallons weighing 60 lbs when full
These are much different than Quick Dam flood barriers. They use water to divert water. The Hydrabarrier Standard barrier is a tube that can be filled with water. The biggest advantage of having this kind of flood barrier is reusability. Unlike any water activated barrier or sandbags, it can be use flood after flood. They are available in different lengths but has a width of 8” and height of 4”.
The best thing about tubes is that hardly take any space. When not in use, you can deflate and fold it. The Hydrabarrier Standard Water Diversion Tubes are made out of high-quality industrial strength vinyl. Vinyl is highly durable if stored properly. The other best part is that filling the water in it is easy. It uses Blue HydraFill adapter which is sold separately.
The Hydrabarrier Standard Water Diversion Tubes are a good option if you want to prepare your property for flood or leakage in advance. Because of so many variants, you can set different kinds of barriers. After considering all tests and reviews, we believe it is among the best water filled flood barriers for homes.
3. UpNorth Sand Bags – Best As Budget Option
- HEAVY DUTY BUILD: DOUBLE-SEWN bottom for extra strength, RIGID Heat-cut top for easy fill
- HEAVY DUTY MATERIALS: 33 grams each, 850 denier count, 10 x 10 tubular weave
- HEAVY DUTY BOX for convenient storage , AFFORDABLE, RE-USABLE, VERSATILE: flood protection, construction projects, water...
Sandbags are the most cost-effective flood barriers. They do require workforce to deploy it they are effective. Especially, if you know there will be heavy flood, sandbags will be your best form of defense. The UpNorth provide high-quality sand bags for flood control. You can buy in bundles depending on your need. There is nothing fancy about these sand bags. They are simple polypropylene.
We tested these bags to see how resistant they are against water. They are not only water resistant, but they are pest resistant. They are loosely weaved to allow the sand to breathe. Even when stacking several bags over each other, they stay in formation and doesn’t roll over easily. But make sure you fill it loosely so that it doesn’t roll off. Once, used you can clean them with water and store it for future use.
If you live in an area that is prone to flood, a permanent barrier of sand bags would be a good option. They hardly cost anything compared to other flood barriers.
4. Quick Dam Flood Gate – Best For Doors & Windows
- One Quick Dam Flood Gate that fits doorways and openings 30-in to 35-in wide and blocks flood water
- Flood Gates seal off doorways & stop flood water from entering. Can be used inside or outside to stop water in its path
- Expandable Sturdy Steel Frame is Easy to use, Install, Store & Transport
If you are specifically looking for something that can be installed at the doorways, there is no other better option than a flood gate. It creates almost wall-like structure to keep the water out. It has protection height of 26” which is highest among the Quick Dam products. And the shelf life of the product is indefinite.
When we installed it for the first time, it hardly took two minutes. It means you can install the barrier as soon as flood hits your place. It uses a sturdy frame with a scissor jack. It can be expanded up to 5” and require no further alterations. There are various other sizes depending on the size. Considering its adjustability, it can fit in to a doorway with 30”-35” opening.
If you want to protect your house against the water with a level beyond 20” Quick Dam Flood Gate is a great preventive measure.
5. New Pig Mildew-Resistant Absorbent Sock – Best For Spills
- Flexible socks stop leaks, drips and condensation from freezers, coolers, windowsills and sliding glass doors. Also...
- Polypropylene skin resists tearing; reduces dust and holds in liquid, even when it's fully saturated
- Designed to keep your home dry. This sock absorbs water and can be left down long-term without growing mildew
For containing spills, or leakage you do not need sand bags or water activated barrier, rather a water absorbing barrier is much more efficient. It is because, for the spill, you are looking to remove the water and not divert it. The New Pig Mildew-Resistant Absorbent Sock is one of the most popular water absorbing barriers we tested.
While we were testing, we exposed it to all kinds of liquid which it can absorb. Within a minute, it began to absorb the liquid. As it absorbed more and more liquid it grew. We also exposed to a higher amount of liquid. Once it has absorbed the liquid to its limit, it won’t absorb more. Hence, it is not useful if the water is flowing. It works well if you have to manage spill.
If you are looking for something that can contain and clean the spills or leakage, the New Pig Mildew-Resistant Absorbent Sock is a great option.
6. Snake Sandbags Single Self-Fill Kit – Best For Flooding
- Lightweight - 6 Foot Snake Sandbags requires approximately 22 pounds of sand
- Durable -Tear-resistant with heavy-duty reinforced stitching
- Flexible - Bend in curves and around corners
The Snake Sandbags Single Self-Fill kit is also similar to absorbent socks, but instead of fillers, they use sand. It is a much cheaper option compared to absorbent socks. These are useful for diverting the water. It is not designed for heavy flood, but for small water leakage. There are number of variants depending on the size.
If you want to arrange them to create a wall that can offer protection against a certain level of water, you can stack them in a pyramid formation. We observed that when it is tightly filled with sand, it is not easy to form a wall. But if you keep it loose, it is much easier. It works in almost all kinds of weather. Even when exposed to the sun for a long period, the material is not affected.
In plumbing emergencies, where you have to divert the flow of water, something like Snake Sandbags Single Self-Fill Kit is a highly effective option.
7. FloodSax Sandless Sandbag – Best Alternative For Sandbags
- Sandless Sandbags: These compact, lightweight sandbags work as a superior flood wall barrier protection and absorbent...
- Superior Protection: These heavy duty 19 x 20 inch bags absorb up to 5.8 gallons and are perfect for indoor or outdoor...
- Innovative Design: These water absorbent flood control barriers feature a 9 section design for ultimate stackability....
Sandbags are widely used for heavy flood. And there are not many alternatives when it comes to diverting, hundreds of gallon of water. FloodSax Sandless Sandbag is one of the few options that you can deploy for such critical situation. When you buy them, they are vacuum sealed and barely weigh anything compared to a sandbag. It’s like buying a vacuum sealed new pillow.
One thing that impressed us is that it is made of biodegradable material. When exposed to ultraviolet light the polymers used in it will biodegrade safely. Yes, this alternative is expensive compared to sandbags, but you can deploy it much quickly without using a lot of manpower.
If you want something that is as effective as sand bags but can be deployed as soon as the crisis arises, then go for FloodSax Sandless Sandbag. It is the best temporary flood protection barriers we have tested.
Buyer’s Guide – What To Consider?
There are a lot of variants when it comes to flood barriers. All have their features and protect against flood in different ways. Some are designed for small leakage and spills while some are designed to fight full-fledged food. Hence, it is important to understand the factors that will help you make the right choice. Go through these factors to have a better understanding of flood barriers.
There are several ways flood barriers work. But there are two prime ways, a flood barriers works. It either absorbs the water or uses filler to divert the water. Hence, you classify flood barriers into absorbing flood barriers and filler flood barriers.
They are usually used for controlling the spills, or leakage. If water is leaking into your house due to flood, or from any equipment, these type of flood barrier are designed to absorb the liquid. They are not suitable for controlling the continuous flow of water because once they reach saturation, they stop absorbing the water. New Pig Absorbent Sock is one of the most effective absorbing flood barrier.
The main purpose of the filler is to form a solid barrier that can divert flowing water. There are several fillers used in the flood barrier. The most basic one is sand. Simple sandbags use sands as a filler, and when stacked to form a wall, they can divert heavy flood. More advanced flood barriers use water activated fillers. When they come in contact with water, they rise to form water diverting barrier. These advanced barriers have an advantage over sand bags as they are easy to deploy and have high shelf-life. Best example of water activated flood barrier is Quick Dam Flood Barrier.
The size of the flood barrier is a crucial factor. When you are buying you, have to keep in mind where you want to deploy the flood barriers. Depending on the location you choose the right size of the barrier. For doorways, you may need a unit that may not be wide but must have a height of more than 20”. If you are looking to stop the spill or leakage, you require a flood barrier that can be stacked length wise to control the spill. Our list covers flood barrier with different sizes. For doorways, something like Quick Dam Flood Gate is good option. If you want to contain spills or leakage, go for New Pig Absorbent Sock.
If your home or workplace is situated in a flood-prone area or own equipment that is cause for spills, you don’t want to spend money every time flood hits your place. A reusable flood barrier is much more cost effective than use and throws flood barrier. Most of the flood barrier on our list are reusable. Either you have to wash and dry them after the use or just remove the filler to store them again safely.
4. Shelf Life
Shelf life refers to the age of the flood barrier without being used. Just like any other commodity flood barrier to have an expiry date. The good thing is flood barriers have more than ten years of shelf life. If you are buying flood barrier that uses sand as filler, you don’t have to worry about the shelf life, but when you’re buying water activated flood barriers, you have to check the shelf life. Each manufacturer offers detail on the shelf life of the flood barrier.
How Did We Test These Products?
We began our testing process by shortlisting flood barriers that are either popular or best sellers. With the help of 12 experts which included four sellers, we were able to shortlist 17 flood barriers that had a good reputation or the sales numbers. Next, we acquired each 17 flood barrier for testing. Before testing, we had to determine the parameters for the tests.
Considering the design and the way the flood barrier is used, we were able to determine the factors that make the flood barrier. Once we were sure about the parameters, we began our tests. For each model, we had designed several tests. We made sure any test we design resembles real life situation so that the effectiveness of the unit is properly tested. And the tools we use for taking a different measurement, we make sure they are accurate and well calibrated.
In addition to the test, we also contacted several existing users of each model of the flood barrier. We heard their experience and views on the flood barriers they use. This gave us a much better idea on the way the flood barrier performs. After we had all the test results and heard user feedbacks, we asked our team to score each flood barrier based on three factors—deployment, re-usability, and effectiveness. After calculating the overall score, we were able to sort the seven flood barriers. Here is the scorecard:
|Quick Dam Flood Barrier||98.4||97.6||97.3||97.7||Check Price|
|Hydrabarrier Standard||96.9||98.2||97.8||97.6||Check Price|
|UpNorth Sand Bags||96.3||97.4||97.6||97.1||Check Price|
|Quick Dam Flood Gate||97.2||97.1||96.7||97.0||Check Price|
|New Pig Mildew-Resistant||97.8||96.7||96.1||96.8||Check Price|
|Snake Sandbags||96.1||96.9||96.5||96.5||Check Price|
|FloodSax Sandless||96.6||96.9||95.8||96.4||Check Price|
Flood barriers help you avoid damage caused by water. It is all about being prepared for the worst. Hence, you have to find the best possible flood barrier that helps you cover all the areas prone to flood, leakage, etc. Our list of flood barriers has products that are tested and well researched. Make sure you stick with them. If you have any confusion about which to buy, go through our buyer’s guide for more information.