Smart scales are a great way to measure health. Several fitness brands offer scales that provide connectivity. After doing testing we have come up with this side by side comparison between Withings scale and Fitbit Aria 2.If you are baffled to choose between these two then this details review will help you.
Withings Scale Vs Fitbit Aria 2 Comparison Chart
|Specifications||Withings||Fitbit Aria 2|
|Wi-Fi||2.4 GHz 802.11 b/g/n||2.4 GHz 802.11 b/g/n|
|Weight limit||Up to 400lbs||Up to 400lbs|
|Users||Up to 8||Up to 8|
|Position control technology||Yes||No|
|Pregnancy tracker and baby mode||Yes||No|
|Amazon Alexa support||Yes||No|
|App Compatability||Over 100 Android and iOS fitness apps||Over 200 Android and iOS fitness apps|
|Type of cells||AAA batteries||AA batteries|
|BMI, Lean Mass and Body Fat Percentage||Yes||Yes|
|Water % Plus Muscle and Bone Mass||Yes||No|
|Size||12.8 x 12.8 x 0.9 in||14.2 x 14 x 1.6 in|
|Price||Check Price||Check Price|
Differences Between Withings Scale Vs Fitbit Aria 2
1. Water, Muscle Mass And Bone Mass
Both the devices cover the baseline weight, body fat percentage, lean mass and BMI. However, Withings has an edge here. It provides data on water percentage, muscle and bone mass. So Withings is the winner here because of the kind of data it provides.
2. Position Control Technology
Withings has a position control technology. We tested the variability in measurements in different positions. The Withings scale showed us the appropriate stance to ensure precision. Having a scale tilted at a certain angle or using it on a different material can alter the readings. But this guidance system helps in ensuring that the right position is maintained.
Fitbit Aria 2 provides some recommendations. The recommendations include laying the scale on a flat surface. However, no feature renders support while the reading is being taken.
3. Pregnancy Tracker, Baby Mode
This is a feature that is unique in the Withings scale. This feature helps expecting mother track their weight. Using obstetrician reviewed advice, it helps mothers maintain a healthy weight. Apart from this, the Baby mode allows the person to easy way infants. Most of the traditional scales do not offer such convenience.
Fitbit Aria 2 doesn’t have this feature.
4. Weather Forecast
Withings Body +Scale tops this as well. It shows you the weather report every morning. This way you can adjust your fitness activities based on the forecast. All you have to do is step on your scale in the morning.
Fitbit Aria 2 doesn’t have this feature. This technology is a perk and offers convenience. However since it is not directly related to fitness, Aria 2 can’t be blamed for not featuring this.
5. Amazon Alexa
Withing Scale syncs with the Health mate app on a day to day basis. It integrates well with Amazon Alexa. Once again, this feature is absent in Fitbit Aria 2.
6. App Compatibility
When it comes to compatibility, Aria 2 pulls right ahead. It is a part of the Fitbit brand. This is probably one of the largest smart fitness product lines. Fitbit Aria 2 integrates with over 200 androids, iOS as well as Windows apps.
The Withings scale has the support of over 100 apps. This is quite impressive, however, it can’t beat the kind of support that Aria 2 provides. In case you are looking for a scale that will integrate with almost any app, Aria 2 should be your go-to.
It is hard to compare the power usage in both devices. Withings Body+ scale uses 4×1.5 AAA batteries. The battery life of this cell is around 18 months. Fitbit Aria 2 uses 3 1.5V size AA batteries. The battery life is not provided.
Since we can’t be sure about the power consumption, it is difficult to conclude. The AA batteries usually last longer than AAA cells. However, nothing much can be said due to the lack of information.
Withings can store up to 16 readings in case it is unable to sync with your device. So even if you don’t have your phone in hand, this feature can be a perk. Fitbit Aria has no such storage feature. So once again Withings scale pulls ahead.
Things In Common Withings Scale Vs Fitbit Aria 2
1. Automatic Synchronization
Withings Scale and Fitbit Aria 2 sync with the fitness app. Withings syncs with the Health Mate app while Fitbit Aria 2 syncs with the Fitbit app. Due to this auto-sync feature, we saved time in uploading the data. We were able to spend more time exploring the other features offered by the device.
Both scales allow up to 8 users to keep track of their health. The scale can automatically distinguish between the users. This way every person can access their health record without any hassle.
3. Nutrition Tracking
Both devices are linked to their respective apps. Due to this, you will be able to keep track of your nutrition as well. It uses the MyFitnessPal or the meal planner and Calorie budget feature in case of Aria. You can set your target weight and monitor your daily calorie intake through this.
4. Weight Range
These models support a wide range when it comes to weight. Withings supports up to 366 pounds while Fitbit scales up to 400 pounds. Majority of the people are covered in this range.
Withings measures more metrics than Aria. In terms of accuracy, both the scales lie in the same category. Fitbit, as well as Withings, have 4 weight sensors. These provide highly accurate results. So regardless of your choice, the accuracy will remain pretty much the same.
6. The Accessories
a) Fitbit Flyer Headphones
These headphones have a playtime of 6 hours. They charge quickly as well. The Bluetooth is built-in. So this way the device can pair with whatever music you prefer.
b) Fitbit charger 3
This is a fitness watch that is waterproof up to 50 meters. It is the perfect device to carry in case you wish to swim. It measures sleep data and indicates any smartphone notifications.
c) The Fitbit Alta HR is slimmer. It tracks your heart rate and provides basic fitness features.
d) Fitbit Flex 2 is a great swim-proof model. It comes with life-proofing. The design is simple and is not accompanied by excess features.
e) The Withings scale has limited integration. You can look into the Nokia Steel HR Hybrid Watch. This device provides 24/7 seamless tracking. You can track your running, swimming, walking and 10 other activities through this. It measures the calories burned as well as the distance travelled. Apart from this it also tracks your sleep cycle. The automatic synchronization ensures that the data is available on your app. The data can be visualized easily through the Nokia Health Mate app. The battery life is 8 months. So you don’t have to worry about charging for quite some time.
Features And Design Of Fitbit Aria 2
- Measures weight, body fat percentage, lean mass and BMI
- Syncs stats automatically to your Fitbit dashboard using Wi-Fi encryption and tracks your progress with simple,...
- Recognizes up to eight users while keeping individual stats private.Measurement range- 4.5-180 kg
The device maintains a record of the weight, body fat percentage, BMI and lean mass. It keeps a track of your trends and measures your progress in the form of charts and graphs. Fitbit Aria 2 permits up to 8 users and keeps the results private. The setup is easy and can be completed within a few minutes using Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. It automatically syncs the statistics to computers and apps. Besides, the app motivates you to reach your target. The device works well with the Fitbit watch and wristband as well. It has a polished glass surface and a sophisticated sleek design.
- Display- It has a Backlit LCD.
- Battery and Power- it uses 3 AA batteries
- It is water-resistant and well designed to work in humid conditions.
- Sizing- 12.3×12.3×1.3 inches
- Weight- 4.7 lbs
- Items in the box- Fitbit Aria 2, Aria 2 Wifi Smart Scale, 3 AA batteries
Features And Design Of Withings Scale
- FULL BODY COMPOSITION - Monitors weight (kg, lb, st), body fat & water %, plus muscle & bone mass. Accurate weight...
- HIGHLY COMPATIBLE - this smart scale syncs with Apple Watch plus more than 100 top health and fitness apps including...
- AUTOMATIC SYNCHRONIZATION - Data from every weigh-in appears automatically via Wi-Fi in the free Health Mate app.
Withings scale provides full body composition analysis. It monitors weight, body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass. The data is automatically synchronized with the Health Mate app via Wifi. The device helps you in tracking your nutrition by keeping a track of your calorie intake. Apart from this, it provides you with a localized weather report every day. The position control technology enhances its accuracy.
- Scale-It has a large, high strength tempered glass platform. The casing is white. The device has an ultra-slim design. The dimensions are 12.8×12.8×0.9 inches.
- Storage- It provides free and unlimited online storage of readings. The device can record up to 16 readings if the scale is not synced.
- Power supply – 4x 1.5V AAA cells with a battery life of 18 months.
- Connectivity- Bluetooth
- Weight- 396 pounds
- Items in the box-Withings Scale, Scale, 5 V AAA cells, Installation guide, Free health mate app, Free Withings account
1. How accurate are the readings?
With any device, there will be some misinterpretation. However, the Withings model maintains high accuracy. It takes into account your body style. The device uses electromagnetic impulses to determine fat composition. Both devices are designed to give the best readings possible.
2. Do these devices connect well with the apps?
These devices keep all your information private. They are designed to automatically sync with the apps and transfer the data through wifi.
3. How are these devices in comparison with each other?
The real difference is in the features. Withings provides a variety of features. Aria, on the other hand, has extensive customer service and brand value.
4. Do these devices work well with the current smartphones?
Both devices can be synced with a wide range of applications on Android, iPhone or windows. Aria works best with Fitbit while Withings accepts over 60 software. These have been designed to function with the wide range of devices we use.
If you are looking for advanced technology and extensive features, Withings should be your go-to. However in case you are looking for a device that integrates well with a larger ecosystem, then Fitbit Aria is a clear choice. It is not possible to declare a clear winner. The choice lies in your hands. You can choose the model that best fits your requirements.