The Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven Under $200 – Awesome Picks

The air fryer toaster oven is making waves in the market as it is a versatile kitchen appliance. The model is almost like an air fryer combined with an oven. It helps you prepare a leisurely meal or quick dinner for your family. 

We have reviewed and tested the best air fryer toaster oven for under $200 and provided you with a list of them. We thought the Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven was the best pick, as it came with 12 preset functions and solid construction. 

Besides, we found that the NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven was our runner-up. It has Linear T technology and 4 rack positions for sublime cooking. Read on to find out more about the list that we have prepared for you. 

Our Top Choice (our top three):

1. Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven (Editor’s choice)
2. NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven (Runner Up)
3. Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven (Budget Pick)

Best air fryer toaster oven under $200

The air fryer toaster oven is a convenient kitchen appliance that comes infused with outstanding features inside it. We can use it for reheating leftover food items, frying potatoes, baking cakes, preparing pizzas, and many more. 

These models also come embedded with exceptional settings, functions, and a wide range of programming facilities that enable us to cook according to our preferences. With the help of participants and volunteers, our team has researched some of the best air fryer toaster ovens under $200 and came up with this list. 

Without wasting further time, let us delve into the list.

1. Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven – Editor’s Choice

The Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven is our first model on the list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $200. This compact and sleek model reminded us of a small convection oven, where we could complete all our cooking tasks.

The model comes produced with a simple LCD display present at the front of it, providing us with the display. Moreover, our participants found it to be exceptionally lightweight and somewhat portable.

There are 5 all-over heating elements offering ample cooking options. We were able to choose what we wanted and then cook it. We could setup up 6 slices of bread, bake cakes, roast a whole turkey, slow cooking up to 10 hours, and make pizzas & more.

Thanks to the 360-degree quick cook technology, and five super heating elements, our meals were able to get adequately cooked on all sides. We found that the food items did not have any fat in them or grease present on them.

It came with a barrage of cooking options like bake, rotisserie, dehydrate, reheat, roast, broil, pizza, slow cook, and reheat. The construction of the model is fantastic, and we found that though it was XL in size, we could place it with sufficient space left on the kitchen countertop. 

We were pleasantly surprised to find a cookbook written by Emeril. Overall, it is a fantastic product that can produce meals for a small family. The design, construction, and features are splendid. 

Bottom line:

The Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven is our editor’s choice. It comes infused with a wide range of features, including elegantly designed, sturdy build quality, fantastic memory features, and quick cook technology.

2. NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven – Runner Up

Second, on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $200 is the NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven. Why the NUWAVE? Let us read and find out. NuWave is an American manufacturer producing environmentally friendly kitchen appliances with the help of the latest culinary technology.

We knew we were dealing with something extraordinary when we got this model. We were instantly taken aback by this model’s opulent design and solid build quality. Our participants could make adjustments quickly. The intuitive digital controls are easy to operate. 

They are present at the top and at the bottom of the toaster oven. The convection fan operates elegantly, providing us with true surround cooking. Moreover, we could set cook temperatures from 50°F to 500°F.

These were much better than the earlier modes that regulate temperature by turning the heater on and off. We also liked the integrated smart digital thermometer in the toaster oven. This model is able to set the temperature accordingly and automatically ends the cooking process.

There is the carryover cooking mode, where the food item that is placed inside the toaster oven is not overcooked. A notable feature that we liked in this model is the 4 rack positions and multi-purpose racks.

We could cook food consisting of 30 pounds at least. We were able to prepare meals for 10-15 adults in one go. All in all, it is a great kitchen appliance that can improve cooking and reduce the time to prepare food items for the family. 

Bottom line:

The NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven is our runner-up on this list. It comes with several features like; you can make easy adjustments, Intuitive digital controls, and linear thermal (linear T) technology.

3. Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven – Budget Pick

The Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven is third on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $200. We were amazed to know that it is a number-one seller on several retail sites, and it is not surprising to see why. 

We were blown away by the compact size of this product. It quickly fitted our kitchen countertop, unlike some large-sized models. We noticed that the look, finish, and design was simply excellent.

It helped us cook like an oven, where the air circulates naturally inside the toaster oven faster, and even cooking. We were impressed with the many features and cooking functions, including toasting, baking, broiling, and helping keep the food warm.

There is a 30-minutes timer inside the toaster oven ensures it has the precise toast setting. We got golden brown bread slices, nicely cooked pizzas, and toasted chicken in a typically less cooking time. 

We could also switch the cooking modes with the lever slide to prepare a wide range of food items. The timer and the average-sized window allowed us to cook to our specifications. We could also keep an eye on our food when it was getting prepared.

The unit has a dual-position rack where you can place the food under the broiler. Besides, the high and low racks provided ample space to prepare food items for two people. Unfortunately, the crumb tray is non-removable to an otherwise exceptional, reasonable, and budget appliance. 

Since this is a compact product and will be used by one or two people at the most, we do not see that to be an area of concern. The low quote clearly fooled us that this model came priced with. 

However, we are pleased to say that we thoroughly enjoyed our testing and researching experience with the toaster oven. It exceeded our expectations in a good way. Moreover, our readers would be delighted to know that this product has notched more than 9,000 positive reviews on several retail websites for its unique qualities, like toasting four slices of bread.

Bottom line:

The Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven is our budget pick. It comes with decent features like Toast, bake, broil, warm, a 30-minute timer, and an auto shutoff feature. This model is most suitable for a single individual or two people. 

4. Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven – Best Compact

Fourth on the list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $100 is the Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven. What is so special about this unit? Let us read and find out. It comes infused with digital crisp control technology.

That means the preset buttons and safety features on this model are sublime. There are precision-controlled temperatures, heat sources, and airflow for optimum cooking performance.

We were also impressed with the results. The food items were almost less than 75% fat. This is pretty healthy food. Not to mention, the food can cook 60% quicker than most of the traditional units. 

We liked the removable tray, where you could pick up the crumb effortlessly. Besides, there is also an accessible back panel when it’s time to give it a deeper clean. We noticed that the model does not take a large counter footprint. 

It is just right, but not too small either. We also noticed that the oven tends to get hotter than most of the other models. So, if you have kids, pets, or older adults at home, then you may want to give the unit more space to ventilate.

We are pleased to tell you that this somewhat compact oven is large enough to cook for 2-3 people. Our participants felt that the wire rack and sheet pan are durable and pleasing. The crumb tray is also acceptable, and the size and performance of the model are fantastic. 

Bottom line:

The Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven is the best compact model on our list. We were delighted to use it and had fun working with it. The model comes with fantastic features, including a convenient flip-away design, elegantly built digital crisp control technology, and a powerful heating system.

5. Toshiba Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo – Best Versatile

Toshiba Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is next on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $200. The model comes with 13 different buttons and is highly versatile. We felt it is suitable for those planning to replace a smaller kitchen appliance. 

Besides, our team member was quite impressed as he was able to use it as a full traditional kitchen. Our participants thought it would be ideal for dormitories and break rooms. We liked the large LCD display that came with the model.

The model has a stylish and elegant design with a grey finish that can easily blend inside the kitchen interior. It comes with 6 heating elements that enable us to make toast chicken and cook a variety of food dishes instantly. 

Besides, we loved the fact that it has a powerful 1750 Watts machine for cooking. There are close to 13 preset buttons that are pretty easy to use. We were able to use them efficiently for our cooking. 

They can come ideal for those of you who require immediate cooking results effectively. We also liked the 3 racks provided in there. The model comes with an indicator present on the door glass. 

It is a versatile model offering several cooking modes for users. We were able to prepare fries, nuggets, Toast, chicken, and steak effortlessly. The LCD screen is quite large and eloquent to see. It comes with a 4.5” screen where one can view the display providing information.

We are delighted with this bit. The maker provides a range of accessories like a grill tray, rack, cooking basket, and crumb tray. Does it come with any drawbacks? Based on our testing, our participants noticed that it behaved weirdly when toasting slices of bread at times. 

It takes its own sweet time. Nothing to be concerned about or worried about, but we just wanted to mention it here. Overall, the unit is a wonderful piece of kitchen appliance that small families should consider having on their kitchen countertops. 

Bottom line:

The Toshiba Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is the best versatile model on our list. It comes with a large LCD screen, has simple control knobs, proper interior light, three racks, and a less counter footprint.

6. LUBY Large Toaster Oven Countertop – Best alternate for convection oven

Our final product is the LUBY Large Toaster Oven Countertop. We were instantly surprised at the sheer size of it. This massive toaster oven might occupy a lot of space on your kitchen countertop, but it sure comes with remarkable features in it. 

We can prepare a large cake, pizza, cookies, and so on. There are 4 racks provided in there, meaning cooking for large families in one go is a simple task. A notable feature of this model is the French door design.

It comes with an auto-shutoff and signal bell that reminds us; our food won’t overcook. We also loved the fact that the food was evenly cooked and heated due to the four heating tubes provided in there. 

The three knobs come with a distinct marking line offering the proper direction of the knob to turn clear. We also loved the accessories provided by the maker, including the machine body and bake tray, wire rack, and tray handle.

We loved the French door design. It was a breeze opening and closing it. Our participants did it fearlessly as we were not afraid of burning our hands. Unlike the open-down or side doors, this French door design was not only elegant in appearance but sublime in performance. 

We could easily place a large tray of cookies inside for baking. Having said that, the counter footprint is large, so you will need to have ample kitchen countertop space. Our kitchen countertop was entirely occupied with this unit on it. 

We felt that the dials are somewhat challenging to read and understand because it comes with an arrow that is the same color as the dial face. Our participant did face some timer functioning issues, and it came with no interior light. 

That should not be a problem if you work inside a well-lit kitchen. We operated and tested this unit in a well-lit room, so we did not have any issues with the lack of interior light. But in today’s world, interior light is nothing special or unique, so they should have it. 

Bottom line:

LUBY Large Toaster Oven Countertop is our list’s best alternative for the convection oven. We were delighted with the features offered on the model, including French door design, ease of work with, a large food capacity, and 4 rack layers.

Does a $100 model differ from a $200 model?

If you have read our earlier review on the best air fryer toaster oven under $100, then you might wonder, does the $100 model actually differ from the $200 model? We were somewhat apprehensive about that and wondered the same thing before beginning our research. 

Will it be worth our time, effort, and analysis, or are we simply wasting everybody’s time here? To our sheer amazement, we found plenty of differences on the models that were priced between $100 to $200 and less than $100. 

The size, features, specifications, and, most importantly, the cooking abilities of the toaster oven. We were simply blown away by the performances of the top three models we have chosen as our editor’s choice, runner-up, and budget pick. 

These models have superb potential in them and come with spectacular value to them as well. Our participants were delighted using these models when they prepared different kinds and sizes of food. 

Buying guide – Factors to consider for an air fryer toaster oven under $200

We considered some factors when choosing air fryer toaster ovens under $200. We want to share them with you. Though the factors might more or less relate to the air fryer toaster oven under $100 that we wrote earlier, some criteria differ.

• Capacity

We saw the capacity of the toaster oven. Since we are dealing with models under $200, most of them come with more capacity for you to cook food for several people. They would be very much ideal for small families and two individuals as well. 

It is always nice to own a toaster oven that comes with a large ability to cook food so that it reduces the preparation time. But you will want to know that some food may need more cook time than others at different temperatures. 

We felt that the NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven suited our needs here. 

• Power

We also saw the power consumption. Now, you do not want a toaster model to consume all the power and give you a large power bill at the end of the month. So, we were particular about the watts used when the toaster model operated. 

Some food items tend to take a longer time to cook, like roast chicken or gravy items. Likewise, toasting a slice of bread or frying fries takes lesser time. While some models are appealing because of their features, their power consumption is on the higher side. 

We thought the Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven worked nicely. 

• Preset functions & safety 

We also took note of the preset functions & safety. You know, toaster ovens are not necessarily a fire hazard or something of that sort. But they may cause a potential electrical short circuit and so on. 

Hence, it would help if you made sure that the model comes with several preset functions and have adequate safety features in them. Based on our tests, we found that the Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven was pretty good in this aspect of things.

• Counter footprint

We noticed that the toaster ovens tend to vary in size. You can find both small and extensive models in the market. While some can help you prepare a large number of food items, some can’t do the same. 

If the model has more capacity, then it will require more counter space. So, if your kitchen countertop has limited space, then you might want to decide likewise. You do not want the model to occupy more space. We noticed that the Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven was pretty compact.  

How did we select the best air fryer toaster oven under $200?

We choose the best air fryer toaster oven under $200 based on some of the abovementioned criteria. Besides, we noted if the model offered us crispy food and oil-free food as well. Moreover, we focused on models that came with several functionalities on them. 

Our testers performed tests and put each model through various challenges. These tests enabled us to assess the heating capabilities of each of the toaster oven models. Once the tests got over, we rated the model depending on the ease of use, performance, features, and value.

How have we tested for the best air fryer toaster oven under $200?

We prepared several food items using the best air fryer toaster oven for under $200. Our participants cooked several food items on more than 12 air fryer toaster oven models before deciding on the list.

We mainly focused on capacity, power, preset functions & safety, and the counter footprint. These factors were thought of to be essential by our editorial team since we are dealing with the under $200 oven models here. 

We also gave some importance to the design and the packaging provided by the manufacturer. Some of the models instantly caught our eyes with the sheer elegance in the design. Besides, we were quite impressed by the packaging offered by some of the product models. 

You can be assured that they will safely reach your destination without damage. The makers had packed them correctly, and we cannot expect more on this side of things. Our team members cooked a wide range of food items like bread, pizzas, chicken, and so on, using the toaster oven. 

The results were pretty good, and almost all of the food items turned out better and exceeded our expectations. We were delighted to taste them and enjoyed our cooking sessions with the models. 

We were able to try out some recipes as well, courtesy of the recipe books provided on some models. Moreover, we found the preset functions quite handy because they enable efficient cooking, wherein our participants could also perform multitasking. 

We checked some of the factors that are given below:

• We have verified the assurances given by the manufacturer. Our participants did that by cooking several food items. This enabled us to get a better idea of the efficiency of the toaster model.
• We checked the power and the speed at which the models were able to cook and prepare the food items. Though some food items take time, like roast chicken, some unis were able to cook them earlier than before. 
• The power consumption and the noise level were checked on the air fryer toaster ovens. Most of them were quiet and performed their task without much disturbance. A few models were noisier than the other units. 
• We also verified on the counter footprint of the toaster models. We were quite particular that they did not occupy too much space on the kitchen countertop. 
• The accessories that were provided with the model were verified and checked. Some models came with a recipe book, while others have manuals and easy instructions. 
• We also took note of the additional features present in the oven model. 

The above factors were considered, and based on that, we have prepared this list of the best air fryer toaster oven under $200.  

Why should you trust us? 

We have empowered homeowners for several years now with our opulent kitchen appliance content, including digital content on our website. Our team believes in creating top-notch content for our readers to help inform their purchasing decision.

These items are not just limited to kitchen appliances you may need for your new home or apartment. As of now, we have written several hundred reviews on kitchen appliances and other products as well.

Our editorial team has a vast experience of several decades among them. We spend a considerable amount of time with each of the models and products. Based on the tests, we write the review and ensure it is unbiased. 

Of course, we consult experts in this filed and our research also includes going through live feedback of real customers who have used and owned the product. Besides, these products come with a minimum 4-star rating, consistent customer reviews, and exceptional features as well. 

Only after deciding on the list of phenomenal models do we do in-person testing with the help of our participants and volunteers. After the research phase, we design user-friendly content through posts that can help you make the right purchase.

FAQs

Conclusion

We have concluded our review on the best air fryer toaster oven under $200. Based on our testing, we found the We thought that the Emeril Lagasse Power Air Fryer 360 Hot Air Fryer Oven was the best model because it has several preset options and is durably built. 

Our runner-up was the NUWAVE BRAVO XL 30-Quart Convection Oven, which had the Linear T technology and 4 rack positions for considerable food preparation. We can assure you that the other models have fantastic features as well. 

Did we forget something on this list? If then, please do write to us about your thoughts and feelings. If you have any doubts, please don’t hesitate to write to us. If you found this post helpful, then feel free to share it with your family members and friends.