The Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven for Pizza – Our Ultimate Choices

The air fryer toaster oven is a must-have in today’s rapidly expanding market. They can be used for preparing pizzas, baking, frying, broiling, and defrosting. Besides, some models come embedded with a host of functionalities. 

In this review, we have researched, tested, and analyzed some of the best air fryer toaster ovens for pizza. We have decided that the Fabuletta Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is our editor’s choice. 

It comes with a 32 QT large oven and has 18 amazing functions. The Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is the runner-up on our list. It has efficient power, 5 preset functions, and an amazing warranty.

Our Top Choice (our top three) 

1. Fabuletta Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo (Editor’s choice)
2. Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo (Runner Up)
3. Hamilton Beach Professional Sure-Crisp Digital Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven (Budget Pick)

The best air fryer toaster oven for pizza

Here is a list of the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza. We have reviewed them based on the features, number of racks, functions, and warranty as well. We also checked for the kitchen countertop footprint, and its ability to prepare pizzas.

Let us now read the post to find out our top models for the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza.

1. Fabuletta Air Fryer Large Countertop Convection Toaster Oven – Editor’s Choice

Our editor’s choice is the Fabuletta Air Fryer Large Countertop Convection Toaster Oven. We felt that it was the ideal model for preparing, baking, and cooking pizzas. Moreover, it is large in size, consumes adequate power, has decent performance, and has a warranty as well. 

Fabuletta may not be as popular as other brands like Geek Chef, Hamilton, and Chefman. But in this list, their model is the winner. Let us read further to know more about this amazing model. We could prepare pizza, air fry, air roast, toast, make bagels, bake, cook vegetables, and so on.

We noticed that the food items, including the pizza, came out perfectly cooked on all sides. It also has 18 customized functionalities where we could choose the preset that was best for our current cooking requirement. 

There is also the ability for selecting the preferred temperature and time for our personal recipes. One of the team members prepared a pizza using her own recipe, and it came out very well. 

This model is a large 32 QT 30L that can easily fit a 13” pizza, a whole 13lbs chicken, 9 slices of bread, 5 steaks, and others. We can say that the model made cooking seem pretty easy. There is also the air fry & dual cook function that requires 85% less oil.

Besides, we found the dual cook function also useful. Though we did not try it out, it helps to cook two food items in a sequence. Based on the user reviews, the results can be pretty good. Our team members were impressed with the two-layer glass door and the cool-touch design. 

It comes with a high-temperature-resistant technology that immensely decreases the outside temperature. This enabled us to use it safely and avoid getting our skin burned as well. We were delighted to find out, the maker provides a 24-month warranty and lifetime customer service.

Bottom line:

The Fabuletta Air Fryer Large Countertop Convection Toaster Oven is our editor’s choice. It comes with a host of tremendous features like a large 32 QT 30L, a dual cook function, a two-layer glass door, and a 24-month warranty. However, it is kind of expensive. 

2. Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo – Runner Up

The Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is our runner-up on the list of the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza. Geek Chef is known for producing some of the most amazing models in the market. 

This model comes with stupendous features like it has a large size, 3 racks, and we could prepare food for 10 people in one go. It has a large design that can be placed on the kitchen countertop to prepare 4 lbs of food and 6 slices of bread.

This model has been ETL listed for safety with a 1700Watts power consumption for making it efficient to cook food. It reduces the fats by more than 85% and besides, and we could view the food items being cooked inside through a large glass viewing window.

Moreover, we loved the inner oven light to be simple to monitor cooking. The stainless-steel model makes it durable. There are 7 modes of menu options offered to you. The 5 preset cooking functions include toast, bake, warm, broil, and air fry.

Our participant was able to set the temperature range from 450 degrees F and also comes infused with a 60-minute timer. Besides, we were able to adjust the taste of the food to our taste. 

It also comes with 4 additional accessories. We found a baking pan, an air fryer basket, an oven rack, and a drip tray to get the oils that drop down from the food items cooked inside. We feel that this is a crucial piece of accessory that is often not included in the toaster oven model. 

We were amazed at the customer service of a 1-year warranty, 30-day money-back guarantee, and lifetime technical consultation as well. Their customer support is also there offering you with a 24-hour service.

Bottom line:

The Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo is our runner-up. It has some amazing features like a large glass viewing window, 1700Watts power consumption, 5 preset cooking functions, and the maker offers 24-hour customer support. But it takes more time to cook. 

3. Hamilton Beach Professional Sure-Crisp Digital Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven – Budget Pick

The Hamilton Beach Professional Sure-Crisp Digital Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven is our budget pick. Hamilton has been around in the market producing stupendous models that are priced reasonably.

It comes with a wide range of functionalities and a durable, stylish stainless-steel construction. The model is capable of producing crisp food items because of the powerful air circulation that is present inside of it. 

We were able to prepare meals for a large number of people with a 1 cubic foot capacity. We were able to make 12” pizza, 6 slices of toast, and many more. Our participants loved the fact that it came with 3 rack positions for doing various cooking needs.

The unit came with digital controls for ample cooking requirements. It has an intuitive control panel that we liked to use & operate, along with LCD screen displays letting you select the setting, choosing the timer, and selecting the temperature of the oven.

The model also comes with the toaster oven air fryer combo along with an excellent cooking and toasting performance. We noticed that it had 1500 watts and a powerful convection fan. The fan is able to offer the right kind of temperature ranging from 200degree F to 450degree F. 

The Sure-Crisp air fry function gives you crisp, even browning with little to no oil, making it ideal for fries, chicken wings, steaks, fish, vegetables, and more. We liked that once the cooking is over, the model automatically shuts down.

We want to mention that the model comes infused with 5 included accessories in there. They are a baking pan, a mesh air fry basket, a temperature probe and drawer, a broil rack, and a removable crumb tray. 

This basket allows for better air circulation inside the model. Moreover, it sits inside on the upper oven rack having the broil rack below to take in the fat drippings. Besides, we are also happy with the price of the unit. 

Bottom line:

The Hamilton Beach Professional Sure-Crisp Digital Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven is our budget pick. It has fantastic features including an elegant stainless-steel construction, Sure-Crisp air fry function, 7 versatile settings, and multi-functional cooking.

4. Chefman Air Fryer Toaster Oven – Best High-tech Model

The Chefman Air Fryer Toaster Oven is next on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza. Chefman is known for its stupendous models. We like the fact that it comes with an inner light so that we can our food cooking. 

Moreover, it also comes with a timer. Our team members found the cleaning and maintenance in this model pretty simple. We did use a dry cloth to wipe down. It is fabulous for use inside a small-sized kitchen because we don’t require a separate toaster oven and air fryer.

This model is a 7-in-1 unit where we could air fry, broil, bake, convection bake, toast, and warm. We were able to use the temperature range of 200 to 450 degrees F effortlessly. Some of the food items include preparing pizza, roasting a whole chicken, or avocado toast.

We were able to prepare food for a large number of people. It has a 20-liter capacity that can easily fit in 6 slices of toast bread. Besides, we were able to roast a 5.5 lbs chicken without heating the oven.

We liked the auto shut-off feature in it as well. The toaster oven shuts off when we opened the door. That is a nice thing to have so that the power consumption is monitored. This is not a common feature. 

Besides, it comes with several accessories including a broiling pan, a flat wire rack, an air fry basket, and a removable crumb tray. These items are dishwasher safe, and the interior walls are non-stick for easy cleaning. 

We were also delighted to know that it is UL certified with advanced safety technology for long-lasting durability. The maker has also provided a 1-year assurance. All in all, this is a fantastic product that should be on everybody’s kitchen countertop.

Bottom line:

The Chefman Air Fryer Toaster Oven is the best high-tech model on our list. It comes with several trendy features including a terrific design and built, a 7-in-1 toaster oven, interior lighting provided, and a 20-liter capacity. Sadly, it does not have electronic controls. 

5. Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven – Best Simple Operation

Fifth on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven we have the Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven. We know that it is the second Hamilton model to be present on our list, but they are that good. 

Hamilton seems to have mastered the art & craft of producing some exceptional toaster oven models in the market. This oven could perform all our cooking requirements from preparing breakfast, and dinners, and consumed less space on the countertop.

Our team member noted that it is quite spacious for a 12” pizza and can take 3lbs chicken wings, and 6 slices of toast. We could cook and make food in 10 ways. The digital control was quite intuitive and even remembers the earlier cooking function adjustments.

The model can cook food fast with the air fryer mode and be able to evenly brown all our favorite foods. The unit provides several accessories including 2 rack positions, a metal mesh basket for even air frying, a baking pan, and a broil rack. 

Our team member also noted that it has a basket present on the upper oven rack. This helps with the broil rack to catch the drippings of the oils due to the cooking and roasting. All in all, it is a tremendous toaster oven that has everything that we needed.

Bottom line:

The Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven is the best simple operation model on our list. This unit comes with excellent features like excellent design, powerful faster cooking, it can prepare meals in under 20 minutes, and an intuitive digital display. But it cooks much quicker than the traditional convection oven models.

6. Ultrean Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Rotisserie – Best Oven Rotisserie

Our final product on our list of the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza is the Ultrean Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Rotisserie function. Our team members felt that the unit is amazing, and it has never failed to impress us. 

Apart from preparing a pizza, we were able to roast a chicken. It came out just as we had desired it would. It can do anything we wanted to cook and prepare with it. However, we might want to inform you not to use too much oil inside it.

It helped us keep an eye on the food that is being cooked inside. Of late, we have been noticing that many manufacturers are making products that come with an interior oven light. The toaster oven has accessories that are dishwasher safe.

They are also easy to clean. The power is around 1800Watts which is pretty good. We found the temperature controls between 150degree F to 450degree F pretty convincing. This model comes with a large capacity of 32QT or 30L. 

We were able to make 12” pizza, 5.5 lbs chicken, or 350g French fries. The food was sufficient for 8-10 individuals. Though we faced a small issue when closing it, we found out the reason. You may want to practice closing it a few times until you get the right action. 

Otherwise, it is a fantastic product that deserves to be present in the market.

Bottom line:

The Ultrean Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Rotisserie is our best Rotisserie choice. There were several features it was sturdily built, LED display with control knobs, an interior light, and exceptional 1800Watts power. Unfortunately, we had a minor issue closing it.

Buying guide – What to know for getting the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza

Here are some points that you may want to know before choosing the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza. 

• The size

Yes, this is the first factor that we noticed in the toaster oven model. We are talking about preparing a pizza, which is usually quite large. Whether you want to prepare a small, medium, or large pizza, you need a decently sized unit to do that. 

So, we noted the size of the model. In our opinion, the Fabuletta Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo Toaster Oven fits the bill perfectly as it is 32 QT size. We were able to prepare large pizzas without any hassle whatsoever.

• Number of racks 

The number of racks in the toaster oven model is the second criterion that we were particular about. It helped us cook more food for a large number of people. Moreover, several racks helped with cooking flexibility. 

The top rack is used for broiling, and the second rack is used for toasting bread, and baking use. Finally, the bottom rack can be used for roasting and cooking pizzas. We found the Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo ideal for this feature.

• Ease of use and heating

The toaster oven unit must be intuitive to use. We do not want to be looking at the manual for each step, and it should come with clearly labeled controls. We need to feel confident working with it. 

Moreover, we preferred models that came with several preset functions and capabilities in them. This allowed us to prepare pizza, roast chicken, and fried food items with ease. We also noted the functioning of the buttons. 

In this case, the Chefman Air Fryer Toaster Oven stood out from the rest.

• Useful accessories

Besides the functions and the buttons, we also gave importance to useful accessories. The air fryer toaster oven models are infused with basic features like an oven rack, crumb tray, and a baking pan. 

The models we have listed here come with a pizza pan, 2-3 oven racks, and pans for broiling. We found them pretty useful in preparing several food items. We could make 12” pizzas easily. We found the Hamilton Beach Professional Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven helpful here.

• Sufficient warranty

We felt that the warranty or money-back guarantee is another factor that should be provided. This is when we noticed that most of the models, we researched came with either warranties or a money-back program. 

We never know when things might go wrong with no fault of ours. This is when you would have wished that the toaster oven model came with a warranty. Our editor’s choice, the Fabuletta Air Fryer Large Countertop Convection Toaster Oven comes with a 24-month warranty, while the other models come with a 1-year warranty or money-back guarantee.

How have we tested for the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza?

In our kitchen, we tested, reviewed, and analyzed these models intensely. We did tests on close to 15 different types of toaster oven models. We tested the toaster oven models by preparing different sizes of pizzas. 

Moreover, we also reheated a slice of medium or large pizza on the models to notice their heating capacity of them. Not only that, but we also cooked, baked, and prepared other food items like chicken, fish, and fresh fries in them to notice the consistency in detail. 

Besides, we wanted to find out whether the functions and settings were simple to use. Most of the models that we tested came with the inside lighting feature. That is because we would want to check the progress of the cooked pizza. 

Cooked pizza and roast chicken are two food items that need to be checked often. So, it is beneficial if the toaster oven model comes with an interior lighting feature in them. We filled the rack with food including the pizza and noticed how evenly it was cooked. 

We cooked, baked, and prepared food using three different settings low, medium, and high. We also noticed the ease of cleaning the toaster oven models. We did not want to struggle when cleaning it. 

We are quite pleased to let you know that the models are quite simple to use and clean. Our team members checked if the pizza, roast chicken, and slices of bread came out evenly or were burnt. 

Our participants were quite satisfied with the results, and our editor melted cheese on the pizza and was pleased with the results she got. We also noted and analyzed the quality of the food baked, roasted, and fried in the toaster oven model. 

The models we tested came with an automatic shut-off timer, and large viewing windows. We also checked for the number of racks, functionality, and warranty on the product. Based on these factors we have decided on the list that is provided for you. 

Who is this for?

The toaster oven models that are discussed above can be used by pizza lovers. Who does not love eating pizzas? They are easy to prepare, healthy for the body, and quite filling. During tests, most of our participants were quite full eating two medium slices of pizza. 

Our editors were quite satisfied with a slice of a large pizza. Having one of these on your kitchen countertop comes with many benefits that we have discussed briefly below. Here are some reasons to use the best air fryer toaster oven for pizza.

1. We were able to cook faster: The toaster oven models helped us cook food faster, and tastier. None of the taste or texture was gone. We placed the food item inside to cook or reheat, and it was done in a few minutes’ time. Of course, this depends on the kind of food that you want to prepare. A roast chicken can take some time to cook. 
2. We found it to be quite versatile: The toaster oven model enabled us to cook several food items. Most of the models these days come with several functionalities. Some of them are roast, broil, reheat, bake, and so on. We needed to choose the function, and then wait for it to be done. 
3. We found them with several racks: The toaster oven unit came with several racks. That means, it helped us cook food for 8-10 people in one go. We did not have to prepare the food again. We were able to prepare a pizza, bake a loaf of bread, roast a chicken, and fry potatoes there altogether. 
4. We noted it does not take up a lot of power: The toaster oven unit does not consume plenty of power. Though the cooking is pretty heavy at times, the power consumption was acceptable. When you calculate it for a month, the power bills won’t shake your budget. The models are suitable for a small home, an apartment, or large rural property. Now, you can cook on a daily basis without having to worry about power.

How to bake or heat a pizza in a toaster oven?

We noticed that we were able to bake or heat the pizza using the toaster oven in a quicker time period, than the oven. That is because the model helps in circulating the hot air throughout the oven, which improves the speed of baking the pizza. 

So, this principle of cooking immensely enhances the speed of cooking. Besides, we noticed that there is no compromise on the taste or texture of the pizza. It comes out pretty well almost what you can get from the traditional brick oven. 

Whether you are using this model for personal or professional use, we can assure you that you won’t be left disappointed. Our participants, team members, and our editors were completely convinced about these models’ pizza-making abilities. 

Even when you want to reheat the pizza or the food items, we found that the food is beautifully heated all around making cold areas hot as well. We just needed to make sure that the right functions were used when preparing, baking, and cooking the pizza. 

We also heated a slice of pizza and were delighted with the results that we received. Moreover, it did not take too long because it was done in less than a minute. However, when you want to cook a pizza, you might want to make use of the convection setting for that.

Below are some of the steps that we used to bake our pizza on the above models that have been listed for you. You can trust us when we say this, it was the most delicious pizza we have ever had in our lives. 

• We preheated the toaster oven to 400 degrees F. Then we choose the convection setting (if this feature was there) or we used the bake function. Both are fine for preparing a pizza.
• Place the pizza carefully inside the proper rack of the toaster oven model you have. Then close the door properly, but gently. Handle the doors gently because they may get damaged easily. 
• We baked the pizza for 10 minutes minimum. We noticed that the convection setting took a little lesser time to cook the pizza. Once the 5-minute time period is over, we kept an eye on the pizza. 
• We removed the pizza when the crust became brown in color and the cheese was bubbling. This is a clear sign that the pizza has been baked properly.
• Now, it is time to eat the pizza. We placed the pizza on a plate and added some sauce to consume it.

Here are some tips that you might want to make use of when preparing a pizza for yourself with your air fryer toaster oven. First, make use of a spatula or tongs when you take out the pizza from the oven. 

This helps you to avoid burning your hands. Since the pizza will be very hot, you do not want to end up getting burned. If at all that happens, please get immediate medical attention. Moreover, all convection toaster ovens do not have the same features.

That is why you will want to read the instructions first and then proceed in preparing a pizza for yourself. Doing that can help you heat, reheat, bake or prepare a pizza in the most efficient manner possible.

When to replace your toaster oven for preparing pizzas & other food items?

Preparing or baking a pizza is not your usual cooking task. It takes a lot of time, effort, and dedication to doing so. That is why you require the right kitchen appliance to be able to prepare the proper pizza. 

When your current toaster oven model or convection model is not in prime form, then you will find it extremely difficult to prepare the pizza. The toaster oven model mostly comes with a lifespan of 8-10 years. 

Besides, some of the brand models come with a 1-year warranty. That is why we suggest you keep the toaster oven model as clean as possible. Perhaps, you can dry clean it once you are done preparing the food for the day. 

Maybe on a weekly basis, you can clean it inside out. This helps ensure that the toaster oven model remains functional. When you leave the elements inside the toaster oven for a long time, then they can catch fire or get damaged. 

During testing, we noticed that the models that come with a single handle, tend to break off or get damaged sooner than the ones that don’t. That is why we also have provided you with a double-door oven and recommend it to those who regularly use the model for heavy cooking purposes. 

Besides, you may use the handle gently when removing or placing food items inside it. You do not want to place items that should not be inside. For this, you need to read the manual at least once before using the toaster oven. 

Lastly, then the appliance does not work properly, does not function well, or does not heat properly, then you know that it is time for a change. Repairing it might not be a good option because it may cost more than half of a new model. 

How much should I spend on a toaster oven?

The toaster oven can cost you at times when you opt for a model that comes infused with several features in it. Luckily, preparing pizzas using your toaster oven does not have to be an expensive proposition. 

Most of the models that we researched in our kitchen are affordable, reasonably priced, and come with a good warranty or money-back policy. As you may have read earlier, it was one of our criteria when choosing the toaster oven model. 

Besides, it may vary according to the brand of your choice. We were quite impressed with most of the brands that we tested and reviewed in our kitchen. You just need to make sure that your kitchen countertop has adequate space because you require a large footprint. 

Moreover, when you want more functionalities, it may cost you somewhat further. That is why we recommend that you must only invest what you actually intend to use. We suggest that consider the budget previously.

Why should you trust us? 

You can trust us because we have a combined experience of more than 50 years in the kitchen appliance market. We have tested, reviewed, and researched the best air fryer toaster oven for pizzas by preparing, making, and cooking them in the kitchen. 

We took the help of our participants, team members, and editors to decide on the models that are currently popularly sold in the market. We choose models that have more than a 4-star rating on most of the retailers. 

Besides, we did our tests based on the criteria. Moreover, we have also consulted with international chefs, experts, and kitchen appliance professionals in this field. We have taken their advice, suggestions, and recommendations to choose the best units in the market. 

Additionally, popular chefs who have prepared their recipes using the models have suggested the units that have been provided for you in the above list. It is safe to say that our knowledge extends to this roundup, which we have done, in review, and research. 

FAQs

In our FAQ section below, we have come up with some Q & A to help you find the answers to your common questions. Knowing these answers can help you choose the right model for preparing your pizzas, and other food items.

Conclusion

We have come to the end of our review. We hope that you enjoyed reading the review, and found it useful in deciding on the air fryer toaster oven model you require for preparing pizzas. The models come infused with exceptional features in them. 

We choose the Fabuletta Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo as our editor’s choice. The unit has a large 32 QT size and comes with 18 functionalities. Our runner-up is the Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo as it provides you with 5 preset functions and a good warranty.

Besides, the other toaster oven models can be considered for not only preparing pizzas but also other food items effortlessly. They are easy to operate and can be used by people of all ages. 

If you have any doubts about the toaster oven models for making & preparing pizzas, then please write to us, below in the comments section. We will be glad to solve your doubts regarding these models.